Doow
Doow
Sign up
ALTERNATIVE APPLICATIONS

ADP Screening and Selection Services Alternatives

Should you replace ADP Screening and Selection Services?

Paychex is the strongest catalog alternative to evaluate for ADP Screening and Selection Services.

ADP Screening and Selection Services

Current
Seat-based Payg
0/5
Annual cost
--
Seats assigned
--

This catalog view compares public market data and does not include organization spend or usage.

ADP Screening and Selection Services alternatives

See how ADP Screening and Selection Services compares to 6 alternative apps you can switch to.

PaychexBest FitPublic pricingAvg. switch cost--Paychex cuts administrative overhead by bundling screening with payroll, but trades off ADP's specialized screening depth and global compliance muscle.
AadmiWorth ConsideringPublic pricingAvg. switch cost--Checkr cuts turnaround times from days to hours with transparent API pricing, but you'll lose ADP's unified HR platform and full-service support.
FourthWorth ConsideringPublic pricingAvg. switch cost--Fourth cuts time-to-productivity by embedding screening in scheduling workflows, but sacrifices ADP's legal safeguards and global verification depth.
Keka HrWorth ConsideringSeat-basedAvg. switch cost$1,089/yr$99/monthTrade ADP's screening depth for a unified HRIS that cuts tech stack costs but requires third-party screening integrations.
Top Dog HrWorth ConsideringPublic pricingAvg. switch cost--Top Dog HR cuts per-check costs by 50% for US-based hiring but forces manual compliance processes that ADP automates.
MyhrWorth ConsideringPublic pricingAvg. switch cost--Promises faster setup than ADP, but likely lacks the global compliance coverage and integration depth of enterprise-grade screening.

Paychex and Aadmi selected for comparison.

Annual costTotal subscription cost for each app, shown for the selected billing period.
ADP Scree...

--

Custom Quote

Public catalog pricing. Organization spend is not included.

Paychex

--

Paychex Flex Select

Public catalog pricing estimate.

Aadmi

--

Public pricing

Public catalog pricing estimate.

3-Year Net SavingEstimated savings over three years after migration and setup costs.
ADP Scree...

$0

No migration in the current app baseline.

Paychex

--

After $3,200 estimated migration cost.

Aadmi

--

After $3,500 estimated migration cost.

Team Fit ScoreHow closely the app matches the teams, workflows, and usage patterns currently in place.
ADP Scree...

--

Paychex

68/100

Paychex excels for small-to-midsize businesses seeking to consolidate payroll, HR, and background screening under one vendor. HR teams benefit from unified employee records and simplified billing, but large enterprises requiring complex global compliance workflows across 100+ countries will find its screening capabilities less configurable than dedicated enterprise platforms.

Aadmi

75/100

Checkr excels for companies scaling quickly that need API-first automation and sub-24-hour turnaround. Tech and gig-economy teams love the mobile candidate experience, but traditional HR departments often miss ADP's dedicated account management and integrated payroll ecosystem.

Adoption RiskExpected friction, training effort, and behavior change needed to move teams onto the alternative.
ADP Scree...

--

Public adoption signal for the current app.

Paychex

low

Paychex is a high-complexity migration. Estimated 5 weeks and $3,200 one-time cost.

Aadmi

low

Aadmi is a high-complexity migration. Estimated 3 weeks and $3,500 one-time cost.

User satisfactionAvailable rating and review signal for team sentiment around the app.
ADP Scree...

--

Paychex

4.1/5.0

22000 reviews

Aadmi

--

Timeline & DisruptionExpected migration duration and disruption to normal workflows.
ADP Scree...

No migration needed

Paychex

5 weeks

High

Paychex is a high-complexity migration. Estimated 5 weeks and $3,200 one-time cost.

Aadmi

3 weeks

High

Aadmi is a high-complexity migration. Estimated 3 weeks and $3,500 one-time cost.

Setup & trainingOne-time implementation, enablement, and training investment required.
ADP Scree...

--

Paychex

$3,200

Estimated one-time migration and setup effort.

Aadmi

$3,500

Estimated one-time migration and setup effort.

Integration CoverageHow much of the current integration and workflow surface is covered by the app.
ADP Scree...

--

Paychex

--

Supports 350 native integrations.

Aadmi

--

Feature Match (%)How closely the app matches current feature needs, including notable gaps or risks.
ADP Scree...

100%

Paychex

0%

  • Limited global screening coverage outside North America
  • Screening packages less customizable than dedicated platforms
  • Tight integration requires Paychex Flex subscription
  • Smaller third-party ATS integration library
  • Basic adverse action automation
Aadmi

0%

  • No native drug testing coordination
  • Limited global coverage outside North America and EU
  • No bundled payroll or HRIS suite
  • Per-check pricing unpredictable at high volume
  • Self-service support model
CertificationsSecurity, privacy, and compliance certifications available for each app.
ADP Scree...

--

Paychex
SOC 2ISO 27001
Aadmi

--

Choose This IfThe conditions where keeping or switching to this app is likely to make sense.
ADP Scree...

You already standardize on this app.

Paychex

You want background screening tightly integrated with existing Paychex payroll and HR systems to reduce vendor management overhead.

Aadmi

You need fast, API-driven screening with modern UX and your team manages tech integrations internally

Avoid This IfThe conditions where this app is likely to create cost, workflow, or adoption risk.
ADP Scree...

Public pricing or fit signals no longer match your needs.

Paychex

You require standalone enterprise-grade screening with complex global compliance workflows across multiple international jurisdictions.

Aadmi

You want a single vendor for payroll, benefits, and screening with white-glove implementation support